Attachment A

​Tasmanian Forests Intergovernmental Agreement Contractors Voluntary Exit Grants Program
Rationale for the recommendations of the review

Review decision on the applicant’s eligibility criteria

Program guidelines that includes details of eligibility and merit criteria. 

The Advisory Panel deemed the application by [Company Name] as ineligible for Tasmanian Forests Intergovernmental Agreement Contractors Voluntary Exit Grants Program (IGACEP) on the basis that it has failed to provide adequate information in order to be assessed as eligible against [A,B,C,D,E and F] of the program’s eligibility criteria.

In response to the written complaint received from the [Company Name] on [date], the application was referred to a review officer for further investigation.

Details of the Advisory Panel’s and reviewer’s findings are in Attachment A.1.

Reviewer’s recommendation on eligibility criteria:

Based on the information reviewed in accordance with the eligibility criteria set out in the IGACEP Grant Program Guidelines:

No

Reviewer’s recommendation

Yes/No

Reasons/comments

Reviewer’s initial & date

1

Uphold the decision of the Advisory Panel

 

 

 

2

Change the decision of the Advisory Panel based on the findings for x, x and x criteria

 

 

 

3

Send the matter back to the Advisory Panel for further investigation

 

 

 

4

Send the matter to another officer for further investigation

 

 

 

Assistant Secretary’s decision on eligibility criteria:

Based on the information reviewed in accordance with the eligibility criteria set out in the IGACEP Grant Program Guidelines:

No

Assistant Secretary’s decision

Yes/No

Reasons/comments

Asst Sec’s initial & date

1

Uphold the decision of the Advisory Panel

 

 

 

2

Change the decision of the Advisory Panel based on the findings for x, x and x criteria

 

 

 

3

Send the matter back to the Advisory Panel for further investigation

 

 

 

4

Send the matter to another officer for further investigation

 

 

 

Attachment A.1

Assessment report – Eligibility criteria


 

Criteria

Applicant statement/claim

Advisory Panel finding

Reviewer’s finding

a

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

 

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

On the basis of the information presented to the reviewer, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that: (deal with specific claims here as well)

  • xx
  • xx

 

b

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

On the basis of the information presented to the reviewer, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  •  

c

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

 

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

On the basis of the information presented to the reviewer, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

d

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

On the basis of the information presented to the panel, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

e

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

 

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

On the basis of the information presented to the panel, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

f

(example) X stated that it met this criterion

(example) x met/ did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx

 

On the basis of the information presented to the panel, I agree with/do not agree with the panel’s assessment against this criterion. I found that x met/did not meet this criterion on the basis that:

  • xx
  • xx
  • xx
  • xx